We have sent wholesale applications to well over a hundred brands and distributors while building our catalog. The same five requests come up again and again, and each one has stalled at least one conversation. None of them is unreasonable from the supplier’s side. This article explains what each request is really checking for, and how a new online retailer can answer it truthfully.
1. “Enter your state sales tax permit number”
What the supplier wants: proof that it does not need to charge you sales tax.
Why it stalls: five states, including Montana and Delaware, have no sales tax and issue no permit. A retailer registered there has nothing to type into the box.
The honest answer: explain the situation in one sentence, attach the federal EIN letter and a completed multistate (MTC) resale certificate, and state where the goods will be delivered. If the ship-to address is in a no-sales-tax state, point that out. Never invent a number or borrow one.
2. “Send photos of your storefront”
What the supplier wants: evidence that you are a real business and not a one-off buyer looking for a discount.
Why it stalls: an online retailer has no shop window to photograph.
The honest answer: offer what you do have: your website, your marketplace storefront name, your business registration, and the name and address of the commercial prep center that receives your inventory. Some suppliers accept this; some have a strict bricks-and-mortar policy. If they do, thank them and move on. A policy is not an invitation to argue.
3. “Provide three trade references”
What the supplier wants: to know that other suppliers have been paid on time.
Why it stalls: a new business has no trade history yet.
The honest answer: trade references exist to support credit terms. Ask whether the supplier will open a prepaid account instead, with references to follow once you have a history. Most will, because a prepaid customer carries no credit risk. Offer bank or professional references if they help.
4. “We are not accepting new Amazon resellers”
What the supplier wants: to protect pricing and reviews on a listing that already has enough sellers, or that the brand sells on itself.
Why it stalls: it is a closed door, and some forms even ask you to confirm you will not sell on Amazon.
The honest answer: do not tick a box you cannot keep. If a brand’s policy excludes marketplaces, the right move is to accept it, record it, and not come back in a month with a different story. Brands talk to each other, and a reseller’s reputation for straight answers is worth more than one account.
5. “Here is our price list” (and it is close to retail)
What the supplier wants: to sell at the margin that works for them.
Why it stalls: after marketplace fees, shipping and prep, a near-retail wholesale price leaves nothing for the retailer.
The honest answer: run the numbers before ordering, not after. If the margin is not there, say so politely and ask whether volume tiers or a distributor route change the picture. If not, decline. Buying at the wrong price to “get started” only creates a listing you will have to abandon.
What We Learned
Every hurdle above is a supplier asking, in its own way, “Can we trust you?” The retailers that get through are the ones that answer plainly, send their documents before being asked, and accept a no without pushing. That approach costs some accounts in the short term. It builds the kind of relationships that last for years.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should a new reseller register for a sales tax permit in another state just to satisfy a form?
Registering creates filing obligations in that state. Most new retailers are better served by explaining their situation and providing the MTC certificate and EIN. Take professional tax advice before registering anywhere.
Is it worth applying to a brand that says it is not accepting Amazon resellers?
Usually not. Respect the policy, note it, and spend the time on brands that do welcome marketplace partners. Policies change, so a polite check-in a year later is reasonable.
How many applications does it take to open a first account?
It varies widely. A realistic expectation for a new online retailer is dozens of applications for a handful of approvals. The acceptance rate improves as the business builds a track record.
Related Reading
- Resale Certificates for Out-of-State Online Retailers: A Guide for Brands and Distributors
- 10 Questions Brands Ask Before Approving an Online Reseller, and How We Answer Them
- 7 Documents Brands Should Request Before Approving a Wholesale Account
Work With an Authorized-Source Retailer
MUEENHAIDER LLC purchases only from brands and their authorized distributors, follows MAP and channel policies, and keeps invoice-traceable records for every unit we sell. If you are a brand or distributor evaluating a new online reseller, we are happy to share our documents and answer questions.



